An in-depth interpretation of the political ideology of Civic Nationalism

Civic nationalism is a form of national identity centered on shared citizenship and political values, emphasizing freedom, democracy, the rule of law and inclusiveness, in contrast to ethnic nationalism based on ancestry and culture. An in-depth understanding of the origins, core principles and contemporary challenges of civic nationalism will help analyze the ideological tendencies of political values in modern pluralistic societies.

As a professional platform for exploring political ideologies and values, the 8Values Quiz political ideology test official website provides you with free testing services for various popular political values, ideological tendencies , and helps you accurately determine your personal political stance. This article will explain in detail one of the important theoretical cornerstones of modern national identity - Civic Nationalism.

Civic Nationalism, also known as Liberal Nationalism or Democratic Nationalism , is a form of nationalism with political identity as its core. This ideology believes that the national community is based on the loyalty and identification of all citizens to the national system, laws and common political values, rather than on innate attributes such as blood, race or culture.

The core principles and characteristics of Civic Nationalism

The core of civic nationalism is to closely link national identity with citizenship, which is the basis for building a modern, diverse social and political community.

Shared political values and the civil contract

The foundation of civic nationalism is a shared set of political values and ideals . These core values often include:

• Liberty, tolerance, equality, and individual rights : Civic nationalism embraces the traditional values of liberalism.
• Democratic principles and the rule of law : Emphasis on loyalty and respect for the country’s constitution, legal system and democratic procedures. The legal system is the cornerstone of national unity and all citizens are equal before the law.

Civic nationalism holds that national cohesion comes from citizens' voluntary commitment to and support of these political institutions and liberal principles . Citizenship represents a formal link between an individual and the state and confers rights but also requires citizens to fulfill obligations, such as participating in public affairs and respecting the law.

Openness, inclusiveness and multiculturalism

The greatest characteristic of civic nationalism is its inclusiveness . In theory, anyone who shares these shared values and political frameworks can become a member of the nation through established procedures (such as applying for citizenship), regardless of their race, religion, or place of birth. This open membership is often reflected in jus\ soli$ citizenship-granting systems, whereby all persons born within the territory of the state are considered citizens and members of the nation.

This model provides room for cultural and ethnic diversity . Since national identity is based on political values rather than cultural background, citizens can retain their cultural heritage while enjoying full national membership as citizens. Civic nationalism tends to support policies of multiculturalism, which is the acceptance of cultural, religious and linguistic differences within the framework of common political loyalties.

The ideological origins and historical development of citizen nationalism

The ideological origins of civil nationalism can be traced back to the Enlightenment period (17th-18th centuries), especially its emphasis on reason, individual rights and popular sovereignty.

Enlightenment and Social Contract Theory

This idea is closely linked to the rationalist and liberal traditions. Among them, French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau is considered one of his important ideological pioneers. His "social contract theory" emphasizes that the political legitimacy of the country comes from the active participation of citizens and the "General Will" (General Will) .

“Daily Referendums” and National Self-Determination

The British philosopher John Stuart Mill and the French political philosopher Ernest Renan are often cited as early civic nationalists.

Renan in his famous 1882 lecture "What is a Nation?" " (_Qu'est-ce qu'une nation?_) gives a classic, voluntary definition of nation: a nation is a "daily referendum" based on the "will to live together" among its members. This definition emphasizes that national identity is the product of an individual's subjective will , rather than being determined by objective conditions such as blood or language.

The ideal of civic nationalism has directly influenced the development of representative democracy, for example:

• United States : The 1776 Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution established a national identity based on individual rights, freedoms, and democratic values, making it a classic example of civic nationalism in action.
• France : The 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen is an expression of the idea of civil nationalism, emphasizing the equality of all citizens before the law.

Civic Nationalism and Ethnic Nationalism: The Binary Opposition of Political Values

In the field of political ideology, civic nationalism is usually placed opposite ethnic nationalism . This is also one of the core distinguishing dimensions of analytical tools such as the 8 Values political orientation test and other political value ideological orientation tests . This classic distinction, systematized by the philosopher Hans Kohn in 1944, distinguishes Western political nationalism from Eastern genealogical nationalism.

Ethnic nationalism attributes the survival of a nation to blood ties and considers shared beliefs and/or language to be important cultural elements. Civic nationalism, in contrast, constructs national identity through citizenship and shared political principles .

However, academic circles generally acknowledge that this binary distinction is often a theoretical ideal model . In reality, most nation-states combine both citizenship and ethnicity. For example, the United States has historically been viewed as a quintessential civic nation-state, but its founding also had exclusionary policies based on race and gender.

In order to analyze your political ideological tendencies more deeply, you can try a more detailed test, such as the 9Axes Political Ideology Test , which can help you understand the intersection of different ideologies from a more diverse dimension.

The Practice and Integration Challenges of Civic Nationalism in Modern Countries

Civic nationalism plays a vital role in multi-ethnic societies, aiming to achieve social cohesion and political stability through a common identity that transcends ethnic boundaries.

Promote social cohesion

Civic nationalism promotes social integration by emphasizing shared political values and providing a common framework for citizens of different cultural, religious and ethnic backgrounds. For example, the United States connects its diverse population into a political community through the American Creed. In the UK, for example, during the Scottish independence movement, the Scottish National Party (SNP) clearly advocated that its nationalism was civil nationalism, emphasizing members’ voluntary attachment to Scotland and participation in civil life, thereby gaining support from non-Scottish residents.

Constitutional Patriotism and Integration of New Immigrants

German philosopher Jürgen Habermas developed the concept of "constitutional patriotism," which is closely related to civic nationalism. Habermas argued that immigrants do not need to be completely assimilated into the dominant culture to integrate into a liberal democratic country, but only need to accept the country's constitutional principles and core values. This provides a theoretical basis for multi-ethnic immigrant countries (such as the United States, Canada, and France) to maintain national identity while ensuring multiculturalism.

Further reading: Positioning on the political spectrum

If you wish to understand the positioning of civic nationalism within the broader political spectrum and its relationship with economic stances (for example, with rainbow capitalism , the tendency to combine progressive social values with the free market represented by pink capitalism), it is recommended that you refine your analysis through the LeftValues left-wing political values test and the RightValues right-wing political spectrum test to fully understand the political values and ideological tendencies behind it.

Theoretical Controversies and Practical Challenges of Civic Nationalism

Although civil nationalism is seen as a more inclusive and progressive form of nationalism, it faces multiple challenges in theory and practice.

The illusion of “cultural neutrality”

Critics believe that the "cultural neutrality" and "pure political identity" promoted by civic nationalism are a myth .

• Implicit ethnic bias : Some scholars have pointed out that the "shared values" of civic nationalism often originate from the historical and cultural development of the dominant culture or powerful groups, and therefore may have implicit ethnocentric bias . In Australia, for example, so-called “civic nationalist” discourse is considered ethnic nationalism disguised as civic nationalism , requiring immigrants to assimilate and adhere to essentially Western liberal democratic cultural values.
• The cultural component is inevitable : Canadian political scientist Bernard Yack criticized Renan's concept of a "voluntary" citizen nation as an illusion , arguing that cultural memory is an integral part of any country's political identity. Even in exemplary cases like the United States and France, the nation-building process has an important cultural component .

The Exclusion of Values and the Elements of “Neoliberalism”

In real-world applications, the emphasis on “shared values” may lead to new forms of exclusion.

• Risk of exclusion : Political sociology research shows that in some northwestern European countries (e.g. Netherlands, Denmark), civic nationalism (especially when combined with cultural elements such as language proficiency) is associated with stronger anti-Muslim attitudes . In this context, liberal values (such as gender equality, secularism) are politicized and become a weapon of cultural exclusion , targeting groups whose values are deemed incompatible with “Western civilization.”
• Neoliberal conditionality : Some scholars have pointed out that neoliberal elements have appeared in recent immigrant integration policies in Western countries. These policies are often referred to as "civic integration." This neoliberal element is reflected in the “conditionalization” of residence permits and the acquisition of citizenship based on one’s “worth” and “merit.”

The Risks of Extreme Practice: Toward Authoritarianism?

If taken strictly to its logical extreme, where citizens are required to adhere to abstract “core values” on an ongoing basis, this could lead to ideological testing and constant political surveillance that could sow the seeds of totalitarianism . In such a hypothetical scenario, the country would need to establish a huge police state to conduct constant ideological review to ensure that citizens’ “values” have not changed. This is inherently contradictory to the individual freedoms and rule of law principles that civil nationalism claims to protect.

Civic nationalism is therefore not a static concept but a dynamic and contested political project . Its success depends on whether the country can truly respect and tolerate cultural diversity while pursuing national unity.

Through the continuous content updates of the official blog , we hope to provide more professional analysis on political philosophy and political values, ideological tendency tests , and help the public establish a deep understanding and clear awareness in the diverse political world.